Writing Craft Guide

How to Identify and Fix Clichés in Your Fiction

Clichés come in two varieties: the phrase-level kind that make your prose feel automatic, and the situation-level kind that make your plot feel predicted. Both damage the reader's trust in the same way — they signal that the writer is operating on defaults. This guide covers how to audit for both, how to rewrite them with specificity, and when a familiar pattern is actually doing deliberate, strategic work.

Cliché audit

The diagnostic every manuscript needs

20 phrases to check

Where most phrase clichés hide

Specificity = the cure

For every cliché in your draft

Everything you need to cut clichés from your writing

The two types of clichés

Phrase cliches operate at the sentence level: 'at the end of the day,' 'heart of gold,' 'blood ran cold.' Situation cliches operate at the story level: the orphan who discovers they are secretly special, the mentor who dies to motivate the hero, the love triangle resolved by tragedy. Both erode reader trust, but in different ways. Phrase cliches make your prose feel lazy. Situation cliches make your plot feel predictable. You need a different diagnostic for each, because searching your manuscript for worn-out language will not catch a worn-out structure.

Why clichés feel safe but damage trust

Writers reach for cliches under pressure because familiar phrases arrive quickly and familiar structures feel proven. The problem is that readers process cliches on autopilot. A cliched phrase is skipped, not read. A cliched situation is predicted before you deliver it. The moment a reader is ahead of you, they stop trusting that you have anything new to show them. Cliches signal that the writer is on default settings, and readers notice even when they cannot articulate it.

The cliché audit

Open your manuscript and search for your 20 most-used figurative words: 'heart,' 'eyes,' 'shadow,' 'darkness,' 'twisted,' 'shattered,' 'suddenly,' 'breathe.' For each hit, decide whether the image earns its place or whether it is automatic filler. At the structural level, list your major plot beats and check each against the tropes common in your genre. The goal is not to eliminate every familiar pattern but to make sure each choice is conscious. An audit takes two hours. The cliches it removes save your book.

Rewriting by going specific

The cure for almost every cliche is the same: replace the abstract with the particular. Not 'the sun was shining' but the specific quality of that light in that moment. Not 'she was nervous' but what nervousness looks like in this character's body on this day. Specific details have a quality that cliches cannot replicate: they feel like they could only come from someone who was actually paying attention. That quality is what readers mean when they say writing feels 'alive.'

Subverting vs. using a cliché unconsciously

Subversion requires awareness. You can only subvert the chosen one trope if you know the reader expects it and you deliberately depart from that expectation at the right moment. If you write the same pattern but without awareness that it is a pattern, you are not subverting anything. You are just adding another iteration. The distinction matters because subversion is a skill that takes practice, and it starts with reading your genre widely enough to know exactly which expectations you are working with.

When clichés are deliberately strategic

Genre fiction runs on familiar patterns for a reason. Romance readers want specific emotional beats. Cozy mystery readers want a particular shape of resolution. When you deliver a familiar pattern well, you are speaking the language of the genre's community. The cliche becomes a comfort signal rather than a failure of imagination. The test is always intention. Are you using this pattern because it genuinely serves the story and the reader's expectations? Or because you have not yet thought of something better? The first is craft. The second is the problem.

Write your book with iWrity

iWrity helps you write with clarity and originality. Catch clichés early and build prose that earns your reader's trust.

Start for free

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a phrase cliche and a situation cliche?

A phrase cliche is a worn-out expression at the sentence level: 'at the end of the day,' 'heart of gold,' 'time will tell.' A situation cliche is a structural story pattern that has become predictable: the orphan hero who discovers they are secretly special, the chosen one, the mentor who dies to motivate the protagonist. Both damage reader trust, but situation cliches are harder to catch because they operate at the plot level rather than the word level.

How do I run a cliche audit on my manuscript?

Open your manuscript in a word processor and run a search for your 20 most-used figurative phrases. Common targets: 'heart,' 'eyes,' 'breath,' 'suddenly,' 'darkness,' 'shadow,' 'twisted,' 'shattered.' For each hit, ask whether the image earns its place or whether it is filler your reader's eye will skip. The goal is not to eliminate every familiar phrase but to make sure each one is doing deliberate work.

When is a cliche actually acceptable in fiction?

Cliches are acceptable as deliberate genre signals. Romance readers expect certain emotional beats; thriller readers expect certain tension patterns. Used consciously, a familiar trope tells readers they are in safe hands. The test is intention: are you using this pattern because it genuinely serves the story, or because you have not yet thought of something better? The first is craft. The second is laziness.

What is the difference between subverting a cliche and just using it unconsciously?

Subverting a cliche requires that your reader recognize the original pattern and see you departing from it. If you write the chosen one but then reveal the prophecy was fabricated by the villain, the subversion only works if the reader felt the setup. Unconscious cliche use is the same pattern delivered straight, with no awareness that it has been done a thousand times. The fix is reading broadly in your genre so you know what the defaults are before you decide whether to follow or break them.

How does specificity cure a cliche?

Cliches are abstract. Specificity replaces abstraction with observed detail. Instead of 'the sun was shining,' write the particular quality of light you mean: the flat white glare of a July afternoon, the amber slant of early October, the pale grey that makes everything look underwater. The specific detail could only come from someone who was paying attention. That is what makes it feel original even when the underlying subject is ordinary.