Paradise as trap, not backdrop
The tropical thriller's central irony is that the setting is genuinely beautiful and genuinely dangerous, and both things are true at the same time in the same place. Writing this requires resisting the impulse to treat beauty and danger as sequential: the beauty first, then the revelation of what is underneath. The most effective tropical thrillers keep both present simultaneously, so the reader feels the tension between them throughout. The paradise is real; the danger is real; the danger is partly enabled by the paradise, by the money and the complacency and the willful blindness that tourism and wealth bring. The trap is that people come here precisely because it looks like a place where ordinary dangers do not apply.