Do Kindle Best Sellers Need High Star Ratings?
The median Kindle genre best seller has 4.5 stars. Only 3% of top 100 places belong to a book under 4.0 stars, and 13% to a book at 4.8 or higher.
Based on 3,038 data points. Last updated November 17, 2026.
A Kindle best seller does not need a perfect score. 65% of the rated places in the genre top 100 lists sit between 4.4 and 4.7 stars, and the most common score is 4.6.
We recorded the star rating of every book in the top 100 of 31 Kindle genres on Amazon.com on 17 November 2026. 3,038 of the 3,100 places showed a star rating. 89 of them were under 4.0 stars and 410 were at 4.8 or higher.
Kindle genre top 100 places per star rating
| Star rating | Places in the genre top 100 lists |
|---|---|
| Under 4.0 | 89 |
| 4.0 | 79 |
| 4.1 | 76 |
| 4.2 | 171 |
| 4.3 | 229 |
| 4.4 | 475 |
| 4.5 | 420 |
| 4.6 | 643 |
| 4.7 | 446 |
| 4.8 | 283 |
| 4.9 | 68 |
| 5.0 | 59 |
Fiction charts with lower stars than nonfiction
The three genres with the lowest average are Mystery, Thriller & Suspense (4.33), Sports & Outdoors (4.33) and Parenting & Relationships (4.38). The three with the highest are Self-Help (4.64), Religion & Spirituality (4.63) and Comics, Manga & Graphic Novels (4.62).
In Mystery, Thriller & Suspense, 7 of the top 100 books sit under 4.0 stars and only 2 reach 4.8. In Religion & Spirituality no book in the top 100 is under 4.0 and 28 reach 4.8.
7 of the 31 genres had no book under 4.0 stars in their top 100. Crafts, Hobbies & Home had the most, with 12.
A higher place on the list does not mean more stars
Books in the top 10 of their genre average 4.52 stars. Books on places 51 to 100 average 4.50. Places 11 to 25 average 4.49 and places 26 to 50 average 4.50.
5 books under 4.0 stars sat in a genre top 10 on the day we looked.
Few ratings means extreme scores
Books with fewer than 100 ratings hold 474 of the rated places. 9% of those are under 4.0 stars and 25% are at 4.8 or higher. For books with 10,000 ratings or more, those shares are 1% and 12%.
59 places belong to a book with a perfect 5.0. 56 of those books have fewer than 100 ratings, and the most rated one has 212. The lowest score on any list was 2.5 stars, on a book with 2 ratings.
What you can do with this
Compare your book with the average in your own genre, not with 5.0. A thriller at 4.3 stars sits right at the genre average of the top 100. A self-help book at 4.3 sits well under it.
Stars do not put a book on the list. Sales do. This data does not show what a star rating does for sales. It shows what the books on the list look like today.
How we measured this
On 17 November 2026 we recorded the top 100 of the Kindle best seller list for 31 genres on Amazon.com. For every book we noted the rank, the star rating and the ratings count Amazon shows on the list page. Amazon rounds the star rating to one decimal. 62 places showed no stars and are left out.
This is a snapshot of one day and the lists change every hour. A book can appear in more than one genre list and then counts once per list. Averages per genre are the plain average of the star ratings shown, not weighted by ratings count.
Source: Amazon.com Kindle best seller lists (public pages), recorded 17 November 2026
You may quote these numbers with a link to this page (CC BY 4.0).
Questions
What star rating does a Kindle best seller have?
The median was 4.5 stars across 3,038 rated places in 31 genre top 100 lists on 17 November 2026. The most common score was 4.6.
Can a book under 4 stars be an Amazon best seller?
Yes. 89 of the 3,038 rated places belonged to a book under 4.0 stars, and 16 to a book under 3.5.
Which Kindle genres have the lowest star ratings in the top 100?
Mystery, Thriller & Suspense (4.33), Sports & Outdoors (4.33) and Parenting & Relationships (4.38). The number in brackets is the average star rating of the top 100.
Is a 5.0 star rating common among best sellers?
No. 59 of 3,038 rated places had a 5.0, and 56 of those books had fewer than 100 ratings.
Your book deserves reviews. The first one is free.
iWrity is a reader community for indie authors. Add your book for free, earn points by reviewing a book you pick, and a different reader chooses yours and reviews it. Honest reviews from real readers, no card needed.
Get my free reviewComparing options? Read our guide to free book reviews.