Writing Craft Guide

How to Write Contemporary Fantasy

Contemporary fantasy asks what the world looks like when magic is real and present: not in a remote secondary world or a mythological past, but here, now, in the same cities and ordinary lives the reader inhabits. The craft is in finding where the magical and the contemporary genuinely intersect rather than simply coexisting.

Magic changes the world it inhabits

Contemporary fantasy grounds when

Ordinary specificity makes extraordinary feel real

The counterpoint works when

Concealment must have costs and logic

Hidden worlds require

The Craft of Contemporary Fantasy

Building the world where magic is real

The contemporary fantasy world is built by asking, systematically, what the contemporary world would actually look like if magic were present: not just what individual characters can do, but what institutions exist, what economic structures have developed, what social norms govern magical ability, what the relationship between magical and non-magical communities looks like, what the legal framework is. Building this world requires following the logic of magic's presence through the world's systems rather than stopping at what is immediately relevant to the plot. The world that has been thought through rather than only the plot-relevant parts of it is the world the reader will believe in, even if much of what was thought through never makes it onto the page.

Magic systems in a realistic setting

Magic systems in contemporary fantasy are constrained by the realistic setting in ways that secondary-world fantasy magic systems are not: the magic must be believable in a world the reader recognizes, and its presence must account for why the realistic world looks the way it does despite containing magic. A magic system whose implications would have changed human history if it had always existed requires either the fiction that it is newly emerged or the worldbuilding labor of showing how a world with this magic has developed differently from our own. Writing a coherent contemporary fantasy magic system requires working through the implications rather than just the capabilities: not just what the magic can do but what the world looks like as a result of everyone knowing that the magic can do those things.

The ordinary and the extraordinary in counterpoint

Contemporary fantasy's distinctive pleasure is the counterpoint between the ordinary and the extraordinary: the magical creatures navigating contemporary bureaucracy, the ancient vampire dealing with modern technology, the witch whose magic interacts in unexpected ways with contemporary consumer culture. Writing this counterpoint requires genuine engagement with both the ordinary and the extraordinary rather than using one as mere backdrop for the other. The contemporary detail that grounds the magical element in specificity (not just any coffee shop but this particular coffee shop in this particular neighborhood, with this particular clientele, whose relationship to the magical community upstairs is this particular thing) does more work than the generic contemporary setting. Specificity in the ordinary makes the extraordinary feel more real.

Hidden worlds and their concealment

The hidden magical world is one of contemporary fantasy's most popular structures, but it requires genuine thought about how concealment works and why. The magical community that hides from ordinary society needs a plausible mechanism for that hiding (glamours, institutional suppression, social convention, cognitive dissonance) and a reason that has been maintained across time. The concealment should also have costs: the magic that is never visible to ordinary people loses its ability to interact with the ordinary world in interesting ways. The best hidden magical worlds use the concealment to generate narrative tension (discovery, accidental exposure, the decision to reveal) rather than simply using it as background. What would happen if the concealment failed is a question the hidden-world narrative should be able to answer.

Urban fantasy and its specificity of place

Contemporary fantasy is closely related to urban fantasy, and both forms benefit from the same craft insight: specific place does more work than generic setting. The magical community of London has a different character than the magical community of New York or Lagos or Seoul, not just because the human cultures are different but because the specific history, geography, and culture of each city would have shaped the magical community that developed within it in specific ways. Writing contemporary fantasy with genuine specificity of place requires knowing the real place well enough to make claims about how magic would have interacted with its specific history and geography. The magic that belongs to this specific city, rather than the generic urban setting, gives the reader a world they want to inhabit rather than a backdrop they barely notice.

Contemporary fantasy and contemporary concerns

Contemporary fantasy's best work uses the magical elements to illuminate contemporary concerns rather than simply to provide exciting content in a contemporary setting. The magical community whose internal politics mirror real-world debates about immigration, assimilation, and cultural preservation; the ancient magical institution whose relationship to contemporary democracy creates genuine tension; the magic whose access and distribution reflects and complicates contemporary inequalities — these are magical elements doing genuine thematic work. Writing contemporary fantasy that engages with contemporary concerns requires understanding what the fantastic elements can say about those concerns that realistic fiction cannot say, and using the magical elements to generate genuine insight rather than simply color.

Build your contemporary fantasy world with iWrity

iWrity helps contemporary fantasy writers work through the implications of magic for the world their story inhabits, design magic systems whose rules are consistent with a recognizable reality, write the ordinary and the extraordinary in genuine counterpoint, and use the magical elements to illuminate contemporary concerns.

Start for free

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you integrate magic into the contemporary world without it feeling arbitrary?

Magic in contemporary fantasy feels grounded rather than arbitrary when it operates according to consistent rules and has genuine consequences for the world it inhabits — consequences that the narrative takes seriously rather than hand-waves away. If magic exists in the contemporary world, the contemporary world has adapted to it: there are institutions, social norms, economic impacts, and political realities that reflect the presence of magic. The magic that appears when the plot needs it and disappears when it would be convenient for the protagonist feels arbitrary; the magic whose rules are established early and whose consequences are consistently followed feels grounded. The contemporary world the reader recognizes provides the reality against which the magic's internal consistency is measured.

How do you handle the hidden magical world versus an openly magical world?

The choice between a hidden magical world (magic exists but most people don't know) and an open magical world (magic is a known part of society) has significant narrative and worldbuilding consequences that need to be thought through rather than simply assumed. The hidden magical world requires a plausible mechanism for concealment and a reason for that concealment — why do magical communities hide, what happens if the concealment fails, how sustainable is the secrecy? The open magical world requires building out the social, economic, and political consequences of magic being a known and present force: how does society organize around magical ability, what are the fault lines of access and inequality? Both are valid choices, but both require their internal logic to be developed rather than assumed.

How do you write the ordinary protagonist discovering the extraordinary?

The ordinary protagonist discovering that magic is real is one of contemporary fantasy's most common narrative structures, and it works when the protagonist's ordinary life is established with enough specificity that the discovery feels like it is disrupting something real. The protagonist whose ordinary life is never quite characterized before the extraordinary intrudes has nothing to lose and therefore produces no sense of stakes. The discovery also needs to be paced so that the protagonist's resistance and adaptation feel psychologically authentic: a person who immediately accepts that magic is real and immediately knows how to navigate the magical world is not encountering the extraordinary but simply switching setting. The discovery should change the protagonist, and that change should be visible in specific ways.

How do you balance the contemporary and the fantastical elements so neither overwhelms the other?

The balance between contemporary and fantastical elements in contemporary fantasy requires both to be doing narrative work: the contemporary setting should not be simply decoration for the magical elements, and the magical elements should not be simply decoration for the contemporary drama. When the contemporary setting is doing work, it provides the specific social, cultural, and physical context that makes the magical elements meaningful in specific ways: the magic that works differently in this specific city at this specific historical moment than it would anywhere else. When the magical elements are doing work, they complicate or illuminate the contemporary setting's specific concerns rather than simply being exciting additions to it. The best contemporary fantasy uses each element to make the other more interesting.

What are the most common contemporary fantasy craft failures?

The most common failure is the magic that ignores its own implications: the contemporary fantasy where magic exists but the contemporary world has not actually been changed by it in any visible way, so the setting functions as contemporary realism with magical events inserted. The second failure is the discovered world that requires no adjustment: the protagonist who moves from ordinary life into the hidden magical world without any period of genuine disorientation, which eliminates one of the genre's richest sources of character development and comedy. The third failure is the inconsistent magic system: magic that operates differently in different scenes based on what the plot requires, which breaks the contract of internal consistency. And the fourth failure is the magical world that is simply more interesting than the real world, so that the return to ordinary life — which the genre often requires — feels like a disappointment rather than a meaningful choice.